Wheelgun Wisdom: Running Double-Action Revolvers

Recently I had the privilege of instructing the “revolver day” of a New Mexico Law Enforcement Academy’s Firearms Instructor Course. Fourteen cops were in the class, and experience ranged from a few years to one gent with 27 years in the bag.

None of them had carried a revolver as a duty gun. A couple carried J-Frames as backups. Some had recreational experience with revolvers, mostly as kids. Several had never fired a revolver. The general consensus of the group was that revolvers worked pretty well back in the day, but their ship had sailed.

This struck me as odd coming from commissioned officers. In fairness, my generation was the last of many to carry revolvers as the norm.

REVOLVERS FOR POLICE AND MILITARY

My academy class in 1988 graduated 36 officers from around the state. Only six of those officers carried semi-automatic pistols. But in the months after I graduated, cops in New Mexico transitioned to semi-autos in droves.

By then, the Glock 17 had been around long enough to earn the trust of the law enforcement market. The Glock was a primary catalyst for the switch—it proved that semi-autos could be as simple to run and as reliable as revolvers. Glocks and the other striker-fired pistols that followed are solid sidearms for law enforcement use.

Cops of today can be forgiven for a lack of familiarity with revolvers, but they shouldn’t automatically relegate them to antiquity. Revolvers served very well for most of the 20th century because of their reliability and simplicity. These virtues are no less important today.

When SEAL Team 6 was formed in 1980, the first handgun issued to team members was the S&W Model 66 .357 Magnum revolver. The stainless revolvers were selected for rust resistance in the environment that they would be used. The SEALs fired thousands of rounds per week and became fiercely proficient. SEALs retained revolvers in their kit into the 1990s, trading the 66s for the stouter L-Frame 686. I wouldn’t be surprised to hear that SEAL teams still use revolvers.

The SEALs’ deployment of revolvers may be mission specific, but there is wisdom in maintaining them in inventory. The ability of a revolver to quickly drain water when exiting the ocean is significant. So is the revolver’s resistance to silt, sand, and mud. The simple design of S&W revolvers proved dependable enough for the Navy’s elite warriors to carry into rough country. They train hard and with purpose. Revolvers are as effective as any pistol in their hands.

EFFICIENT OPERATION OF THE REVOLVER

Revolvers are certainly still capable of martial duties—they just need to be operated in the most efficient way possible.

Mastering two trigger pulls on a DA revolver like you have to on a conventional DA semi-auto is unnecessary if you always shoot the revolver double-action. As a defensive weapon, there is no reason to thumb cock the hammer and shoot from single-action mode.

With practice comes the realization that single-action fire is an unnecessary crutch—even at long range. Cocked revolvers, not fired, need to be de-cocked. A simple task when you are relaxing in your garage, but it can be a little trickier when your heart is racing at 190 bpm and your fingers are gloved, wet, frozen, or injured.

The “secret” to running the trigger on a fighting revolver can be extracted from any lesson on the marksmanship fundamental of trigger control: smooth steady pressure straight to the rear.

Once you start pressing, keep the hammer moving constantly rearward until the shot breaks. Release the trigger all the way (to its normal resting position) without losing contact and repeat as needed.

It’s a little weird if you’re used to the short trigger reset of a striker-fired pistol or a 1911. Shooters familiar with semi-autos but new to revolvers tend to “short stroke” the trigger reset. Doing so disallows a new chamber from advancing in line with the bore.

The trigger pull on modern double-action revolvers may seem oppressively heavy and encourages novices to either thumb cock the revolver and fire single-action or switch to an auto. Yes, the pull on a new S&W revolver is heavier than the average Glock, and it takes some getting used to. The way to get used to it is to do it.

DRY FIRE

A good rule when buying a new centerfire revolver is to dry fire it a thousand times. Dry fire “marries” the action parts and helps break them in. The trigger pull doesn’t need to be excessively light as long as it feels smooth.

Legendary speed shooter Ed McGivern made a statement in his classic 1930s Book of Fast and Fancy Revolver Shooting that summed things up nicely. “It is usually the case with double-action revolvers that the more they are operated by the double-action method and the more care and attention they receive, the smoother the actions become and the better they operate.”

That’s the essential beauty of a double-action revolver. Dry fire the crap out of it and it gets real smooth. All that dry fire used to hone the action also strengthens the muscles operating your trigger finger and trains the feel of that smooth constant press.

“Staging” the trigger is a technique better left on the target range. Staging consists of quickly pulling the trigger to the point of final friction and then establishing a sight picture. This leaves the shooter with a short distance for the trigger to travel before ignition, but complicates a simple system.

The shooter has to know the gun well to stage without the occasional mess up. The “feel” of staging the trigger can vary from one chamber to the next in the same gun. Improper staging typically results in an unintentional discharge. Do not try to make your double-action pull feel like a single-action by staging the trigger.

It’s true that the long, heavy trigger pulls of revolvers are more resistant to negligent discharges than most semi-autos if a finger is on the trigger when it shouldn’t be. That fact in no way justifies getting a head start on the trigger press before your sights are on target. This practice violates basic sacred safety rules that apply to all who carry firearms.

Present the gun, acquire sights to the degree required, and press. Your brain is capable of making minor corrections in sight alignment/picture as the trigger travels.

Hollywood provides a flawed training manual for revolvers. Avoid it at all costs. I am referring to the abominable practice of flipping the cylinder in and out of the gun like action heroes do. George Clooney has gun wranglers to repair the damage his shenanigans cause—you likely do not.

The “Hollywood flip” will beat the yoke of your revolver out of alignment in fairly short order. The heavier the cylinder, the more quickly this will occur. Always support the cylinder all the way out to the fully open position and all the way in to the closed/locked position.

RUNNING THE REVOLVER

Several methods work for running a revolver. I trust the late 1980s cop training on the subject (sometimes called the Universal Method).

A right-handed shooter lays the revolver on its right side in the palm of the left hand as the cylinder release is activated with the right thumb. The left middle and ring fingers push the cylinder out and join the left thumb to lock it fully open. The left index finger and pinky wrap around and grip the frame on either side of the cylinder window. Left-handed shooters should reach around the back of the frame with their left thumb to push the thumb piece. The right thumb pushes the cylinder open and joins the right index and middle fingers to lock the cylinder fully open.

Counterintuitive to semi-auto training, the shooting hand loads the gun. The support hand, typically being a shade less dexterous, only has to hold the gun and lock the cylinder fully open. Loading a revolver is a somewhat busier task than sticking a magazine into the magazine well of an empty pistol. It makes sense to use your strong hand for this purpose.

Working the extractor rod is a function best performed by striking it with the open palm of the shooting hand. The muzzle should be straight up and the strike should come straight down. If you hit the extractor rod from an angle, you may bend it and cause binding in the rotation of the cylinder. This is the most “bulletproof” method of emptying the revolver in an emergency reload. It gets spent cases the heck out of the gun.

Granted, it’s a tick slower than using the support thumb (or index finger for lefties) to press the extractor rod while the strong hand fetches fresh ammo. But your support thumb may not have the strength to clear a swelled or split case that can lodge in a chamber and tie up your gun in an empty and quite useless condition.

Murphy dreams about splitting an empty case for you when you’re firing full-power ammunition in a life-or-death situation.

Additionally, using the support thumb is much more likely to gift you with a failure-to-extract condition. If you don’t execute it perfectly, the empties may hang around and give a case rim the chance to lodge underneath the extractor star.

I’ve caused a few of these debilitating malfunctions in matches trying to “game” it by using my left thumb to shuck empties. I have never had a case hang up using the palm method.

After the gun is emptied, the support hand rotates the gun as close to vertical (muzzle down) as possible, while the strong hand seeks fresh ammunition. Keeping the gun vertical allows gravity to assist the rounds dropping fully into the cylinder.

RELOADS

Speedloaders or full-moon clips are the quickest way to reload an empty revolver. Carrying a speedloader takes about as much room as carrying an extra cylinder in your pocket. A lot of folks don’t carry them with a concealed revolver for that reason.

Speed strips and 2X2 pouches are much flatter and conceal better. Even if you carry a speedloader, it’s a good idea to carry strips or a pouch, because they let you top off the revolver if you fire and partially empty it. If all you have are speedloaders or if the ammo in the cylinder is moon clipped, you’ll be mandated to dump live ammunition on the deck to refill the gun to capacity. Speed strips or a pouch will prevent this and are infinitely quicker than trying to load loose rounds from a pocket.

It pays to know which way your cylinder rotates when you’re empty loading from a pouch or strip. S&Ws and Rugers rotate counterclockwise, while Colts rotate clockwise. The cylinder stop notch near the rear of the cylinder has a relief cut that forms an arrow pointing in the direction the cylinder turns if you forget.

With the cylinder fully open, load two rounds at a time into the chambers at 12 and 10 o’clock. As you reach for the next two or peel off the strip, rotate the cylinder clockwise 1/3 turn (S&W). This orients the loaded rounds on the correct side of the forcing cone/barrel if you have to shut the gun and fire during the reload. Otherwise, you’ll click on two-four empty chambers prior to firing, wasting time and likely slapping the trigger frantically praying for a bang.

This technique only works well if your fingers are long enough to keep the cylinder fully locked open. If you have short fingers, turning the cylinder counterclockwise prevents it from unintentionally closing as you load.

A tactical reload may be viewed as nearly an administrative function with an autoloader, but it’s more important with a revolver because of its limited capacity. If you shoot it at all, you should think about reloading. Like pump shotguns, loading what you shoot is a good rule. With both systems, carrying spare ammo is mandatory and reloading skill is critical.

Pump guns and revolvers aren’t harder to operate than semi-autos, just different. Pump shotguns are viciously effective if you’re willing to become proficient with them. Such is the case with revolvers, and they are as viable now as they were back in the day.

Kevin McPherson served as a police officer in New Mexico for 23½ years, the last 19½ with the New Mexico State Police. There he worked in the uniform bureau and narcotics enforcement section and did two tours in the NMSP Training Bureau, retiring as a Sergeant in 2011. Kevin ran the firearms program and was the chief armorer for NMSP for 13 years and served as a member of the NMSP Tactical Team.